Extended Analysis of the General Two-mirror Dihedral (inter-mirror) Angle Case
By Philip Bradfield
Credentials
- MA (Cambridge: Physics), MSc (Aston), MInstP (UK), CPhys (UK)
- Fellow of the Higher Education Academy (UK), STEM Ambassador
- Retired University Senior Lecturer, Private Tutor: Math, Physics & Chemistry
Biography
- Retired academic scientist ā still active
- Born at Derby (1942), and now retired to Dunfermline (near Edinburgh) Scotland.
- TaughtĀ PhysicsĀ at Edinburgh, De Montford andĀ WolverhamptonĀ Universities and then (after a sabbatical MSc) ComputerĀ Science, also atĀ Wolverhampton
- Research Interests: Optics, Solid-State Physics, Physical crystallography, Physics history and pedagogy
I have contributed a new extended analysis of the general two-mirror dihedral (inter-mirror) angle case, (ambiguity of final images) to an International Conference on the History of Physics ( Trinity College, Cambridge: Sept 2014) and to the BKS (USA).
I use a simple polyangular (i.e. variable angle) two-mirror system to explore/demonstrate my results: there is one such from the early days, in the National Museum of Scotland (by Bate (London), c. 1820: designed by Brewster: cf. his 1817 Patent).
To demonstrate my results theoretically, I devised a full computer simulation: ā the output showed the āringā of images formed from any one (asymmetric) object (an irregular tetrahedron was used). The furthest images are āAMBIGUOUSā for a GENERAL dihedral angle ā what you see depends on the choice of EXIT mirror.Ā I used hatching/transparency to allow images āfurther inā to be seen even āthroughā the object for any given viewing direction.
I hope to gain some practical advice from you all, and am very happy to discuss theoretical/mathematical aspects. Feedback requested:
- I have constructed the classic three-mirror ātriangularā truncated cone Kaleidoscope (1/48 of the total solid angle): with a mirrored ābaseā it yields convincing results: I use a simple asymmetric object in the K.Ā i.e. Ā 45, 35.3, 54.7 degree inter-edge angle tapering for the pairs of mirror-edges (tapering angles) cf. [001] ^ [011]; [011] ^ [111]; [111] ^ [001] crystallographic cubic system zone axes. The angles between the mirror-pairs (dihedral: Ā largest angle between the two mirrors, i.e. ānormallyā) are 45, 90, 60 degrees (use a stereogram, as in crystallography: cubic symmetry).Ā The images formed from any object point form āclustersā of the appropriate symmetry around the edges/joints: 8 (4mm), 6 (3m) and 4 (2mm).
- The other simple but āsquareā 3D truncated KĀ (1/6 of the total solid angle)Ā has four identical mirrors, each with tapering angle of 2*35.3 degree i.e. 70.6 degree. (cf. ANGLE BETWEEN [111] AND [-1 1 1] CRYSTALLOGRAPHIC CUBIC ZONE AXES) and the inter-mirror dihedral angles are all 120 degree.
- I believe this is often used in hands-on āExploratoriumā venues, using a suitable TV/PC monitor screen at the base of the broad truncated āsquareā cone.
- The simplest three-mirror K is of course three plane mirrors meeting normally: the classic ācube cornerā: optically noted for its property of reflecting any incident light back along its original path, though transversely displaced unless directed at the unique central common point ā this property best explored using a simple pencil to represent the incident beam (i.e. defined by any two points along the pencil).Ā The object plus seven distinct images are useful in introducing the other 3D Ks: Ā the even and odd chirality (handedness) of these images is clearly evident when an asymmetric object (e.g. hand) is used.









